A day cruiser is a big heavy boat. Anything smaller than an A cut is going to suck everywhere but top speed.
I wouldn't recommend going smaller than an A cut.
Consider this, a larger impeller will be easier on fuel consumption during operation. Are you the type of end user who is out cruising around with the family, or are you out making passes? Where is the engine going to spend most of it's time, peak horsepower or cruising around?
You can cut a larger impeller down, to increase RPM. You can (correctly) detail the trailing edges to reduce RPM, however you can only drop a few hundred RPM. You can't bring a B cut back to an A cut.
Price out stainless impellers. I wouldn't want to guess wrong or be misled at current prices. You will spend an easy $3K with the SS impeller, 17-4 shaft, new wear ring, insulator, and thrust bearing minimum. A BC cut impeller costs exactly the same as a AA cut impeller.
I would try the impeller you have now, to see where your RPM is, then adjust your cut accordingly. It won't cost you anything except that it is easier to pull the shaft with the engine already out.