Is this for car or boat? If it's a boat I would run the 15W-50, since marine engines are pretty much under a heavy load all the time. I've been using synthetic in some of my cars (Toyota Tundra and Jeep Wrangler) and my jet boat for more than 10 years. In a couple of old cars I have, 68 Malibu and 69 Mustang, the synthetic doesn't work as well but those engines are old school builds and I can hear the lifters clatter a little with the synthetic so they get dino oil (if I ever build them again the engines will be run on synthetic). I've had the Chevy SBC in my boat apart a couple times and having run the synthetic it's very clean inside, no gunk anywhere. I use Mobil 1, because it's been around a long time and also it's readily available at a reasonable price, but I'm sure others will chime in with their favorite.