I'm not sure about compression psi numbers but if they are all close to the same then you should be good. On the motor I would look for the rubber boots that connect the end casting to the intake manifold. If they are cracked the motor will run super lean. I would make sure that a lot of the tin is still around the motor like the front and rear plates. Those help cool the engine believe it or not. Also if you do get it get rid of the deck lid stand offs. Those make the motor run way hotter. As far as the way it runs it's hard to say what to listen for, VW are noisy, the valves make a shit ton of noise.