Not all "hooligans" are bad news, but quite a few make us all look real bad. I've had my fair share of run ins with the law, I'm covered in tattoos ( since '85 before it became a "fad") ride a Harley Chopper, and am building your stereo typical, greaser style, heavily chopped and channeled '32 Ford, so just looking at me, and seeing the things I do, you would think that I'm an ex-con, crook, and am nothing but trouble!! But Honestly, although I have had problems and have been arrested.... I've never actually been inside a jail cell of any kind!!
On the contrary, I've been married to my current wife for 19 years, have had my current job for 8, have never missed a scheduled day of work, stay late all the time and was a supervisor at an engine rebuilding shop for 5 years prior to this one. For me, people may not like my looks, music, or cars, but they can't say anything BAD about my work loyalty, ethic, or quality. A person that wants that job will persue it. I knew 3 workers at my current job, and 2 were supervisors, but I t still took me 3 different job apps, and 3 interviews before I finally got that chance. I'm still here, and the other 2 guys that were hired before they gave me that chance are loong gone.
I have 6 kids between an ex wife and my current one, none out of wedlock, have bought and sold 2 houses and have zero credit cards. And posses the titles to all the cars, 2 Harley's, and the boat I own.
Not trying to sell myself for your job or anything here, just trying to give another perspective, or "side of the coin". There are good guys with a checkered past (like me) that do just "need a second chance". I'd suggest maybe going thru a temp. agency, that way you don't have to provide any L&I insurance or benefits. Then you can see how he works out after the guys has been there for a while, then you can hire him if it's a good match, or don't offer a job, and get another temp. thru the agency??
Before the current situation that has happened with my daughter, I had been trying to get a job in L.A. or SanDiego for years, (because Spokane, is cold, rainy, and snowy) and that "arrest record" has sometimes been an issue, even with NO convictions!! My boss knows I want to go back to Cali. bit I also still work my ass off there, and wouldn't leave without a 2 week at minimum notice. That notice cost me 2 potential jobs before, because they needed someone NOW, and I wouldn't do that to my employer!!
Good luck, there rally ARE good guys/ gals out there, just need to find one. Ironically, it's usually hard because if they are a good and loyal "hooligan" they already have a job, and are committed to their employer, like what you want.