GC, here is some "food for thought", my friend Tim in Oregon thought the same thing you did, he is the one that built the T58 turbine powered jet boat, that boat has been tested and tested but if you notice still uses a "12" series pump, now that boat makes 1500+/- HP, it ran up and back a 38 mile whitewater river at a sustained average speed of over 120MPH, what that tells me is the "12 series" pumps have a lot left on the shelf...
I'm not sure bigger would necessarily be any better, I could be off by quite a bit, but then again I am of the mindset that lighter is better, so maybe if the boat is heavier you would be right on que...
I guess this is one of those "wide open debates". I do know that if there was a redesigned pump, I'm not so sure I would ever be able to afford one, its kind of like the VCR when they were first introduced, they were like $600, now you can get one for about $30.

Cool thread though....

GT